By: hines55 | December 31, 2013

Picture


Bear with me... I'm going to take a few paragraphs to work up to my central theme... 

As a marginalized writer of lesbian-feminist plays, I used to wonder what it would be like if one of my plays achieved first-class production (which is the industry lingo for “Broadway-level”).  My question was answered when a Brazilian film and television star ran across a collection of my plays in a bookstore near Union Square, read my play about Joan of Arc, and decided to produce and star in it. In Brazil, of course. First-class production! 

A word about the play: It was a one-woman show dealing with Joan of Arc as a teenaged, lesbian, butch runaway who was returning from the grave with a searing radical feminist critique of her experiences and those responsible for them. She is returning with a mission to warn contemporary women that they are facing the same enemies and that they need to understand this and to fight.   

In other words, an unlikely candidate for first-class production.   




Picture 
Joan of Arc with "Scenic Element"


But, you know what? The show was the top-selling commercial production of the season in both São Paulo and Rio. And then it went on to tour all the other major cities in Brazil. It was a smash hit.   

Is Brazil a nation of lesbian feminists? What could possibly explain this? 

Well… For starts, this one-woman show featured four really beefy, macho men. They rode motorcycles onto the stage, making a lot of noise, but no “lines” per se. This enabled the producer to designate them “scenic elements,” not added characters… which would have been a violation of my contract. 

These four Hell’s Angels would circle Joan, maul her, cradle her, drive her on the back of their motorcycles…  In other words, come constantly between her and the audience. And the butch thing was gone, completely. Joan wore enough eye makeup to put Theda Bara to shame, and she was dressed in tights.   

And then there was the rape.   

Joan was raped in her prison cell in a situation that was clearly engineered to make her prefer death to life. And it worked. She recanted her recantation and was burned at the stake.   

Now, lots of playwrights have written about Joan.. Bernard Shaw, Jean Anouihl, Eva Le Gallienne... and they end at the stake. I didn’t want to do that. In my play she is returning from the dead. The stake is in the past. We are looking to the future. I wanted to respect and protect the survivors in my audience who did not need to have their trauma memories restimulated. I did not want to write a play where, once again, the boys win.   

In the Brazilian production, there was no such sensitivity. The four “scenic elements” stripped down to full frontal nudity and performed the assault on the stage. They raped my character. They raped my play. The play I had crafted to empower and inspire survivors became one more traumatic encounter reinforcing the helplessness of women, always outnumbered by the machine of patriarchy.   

And they screwed me financially. Of course. It took more than three years to recover my royalty, and the amount was not commensurate with the success of the work.   



Picture 
PL Travers


Why am I telling you this in an article about Saving Mr. Banks

Because I am a lesbian writer whose beloved lesbian protagonist was hideously mangled by the machinery of patriarchal theatre, and I was angry about that. Really, really angry. Still am, because the pain of that experience never goes away. And I believe that PL Travers was a lesbian writer whose beloved lesbian protagonist was hideously mangled by the machinery of patriarchal Hollywood, and that she was angry about that. Really, really angry. And now the world is invited to come and mock this thoroughly unpleasant woman.   

I come to celebrate her.   

Was PL Travers a lesbian?  Duh.   

Some insist that she was bisexual, but the evidence for that is very sketchy. Aggressively pursuing publication, Travers went to Dublin to meet the editor Æ (aka George Russell), who had sent her an encouraging letter about her poems. He was married and twice her age, with a penchant for encouraging young writers. Travers’ biographer characterizes their friendship as “filial, intellectual, and marked by romantic gestures.” In other words, he flirted. But more to the point, he insisted that she get together with Madge Burnand. She did indeed get together with Madge, moved in with her, wrote the first Mary Poppins book in a cottage with her, and continued to live with her for ten years in a relationship that her biographer characterizes as “intense.” Duh.   




Picture 
Jessie Orage: One of PL Travers' Lovers


Æ would also introduce Travers to the teachings of Gurdjieff, a charismatic and influential spiritual teacher. Travers’ involvement with the community of Gurdjieff’s followers in the 1930’s should be of special interest to lesbian scholars. In spite of Gurdjieff’s professed advocacy of rigid gender roles, he created a women-only group in the 1920’s known as “The Rope.” The members of this group were all strong, successful women—mostly lesbian—who did not subscribe to traditional gender roles. One of these women, Jessie Orage, became lovers with Travers. Orage had scandalized the Gurdjieff community a decade earlier by wearing men’s trousers and smoking cigarettes. She documents the affair with Travers in the pages of her diary.



Picture 
Jane Heap, Member of "The Rope"



So what about this Mary Poppins? Was she a lesbian? Well, I will argue—as did Travers—that heterosexual romance was not for her. Travers had first introduced the character in 1926, when she wrote a series of stories about children and their dreams. This collection became the basis for the first Mary Poppins book. On November 13, 1926, the   Christchurch Sun   published “Mary Poppins and the Match Man,” a short story about Mary Poppins’ day off with her boyfriend Bert.   

Eight years later, Travers published the first Mary Poppins book, and the most significant change between the 1926 version of the famous nanny and the 1934 one, had to do with Mary Poppins’ relationships with men. Bert is no longer a boyfriend, but a buddy… or, more accurately, a groupie. Mary Poppins has become what one writer calls “untouchable and distant,” but I would use the word “exalted.” She is morphing into archetypal forms. Æ suggested the goddess of destruction and empowerment, Kali—and Travers did not disagree. By 1934, the proper nanny of her earlier stories had begun to supercede the ineffectual mother Mrs. Banks. No one except Mr. Banks, according to Travers, could understand her.



Picture


I believe what we are dealing with here is a lesbian butch. A guardian/ warrior archetype who combines military discipline with a Gurdjieffian mysticism that enables her to ascend to the stars and commune with the animals. A lesbian butch who cannot identify with a haplessly subordinate mother-figure and who identifies more solidly with the bread-winning father who must brave the rigors of a collapsing financial world. 

Disney, by the way, turned Mrs. Banks into a "Suffragette," because in his mind, this was synonymous with bad mothering. PL Travers, no doubt aware of the heavy lesbian butch presence among the ranks of women militating for equal rights, was baffled and unhappy with his choice. Truly, her flighty and uber-feminine Mrs. Banks would have been terrified by the Suffragists.   

But back to Mary Poppins. I know this archetype. I have been working with lesbian archetypes in my writing for thirty years. I find them in the writings of other lesbians, in their biographies, in our spiritual traditions and rituals, and in the lives of the women I love. And they are completely invisible—censored—in mainstream culture. Where they do surface, they are wildly misinterpreted, ridiculed, or demonized. As is the character of PL Travers in   Saving Mr. Banks . Which is more like "Saving Mr. Disney." 


Picture 
Memo from Walt Disney's FBI Files

Disney comes off like “Father Knows Best” in the film, but, in fact, he was a heavy-handed union-buster who, according to documents that surfaced under the Freedom of Information Act, served from 1940 until his death in 1966 as a secret informer (read “spy”) for the FBI.   

And he was a misogynist, a fact reflected in his hiring practices...  as well as his need to ridicule the movement for women's suffrage.The letter below spells out the Disney Studio's  policy:  "Women do not do any of the creative work..."   




Picture


By the time Travers arrived at the Studios, Mary Poppins, the inscrutable and intimidating disciplinarian, had been turned into the gracious, cheerful, idealized playmate for the children. And Bert had reverted to a love interest... something to which Travers took strenuous exception. The heroine of a 1930's Depression-Era bank crisis, wearing masculine suits with huge shoulder pads had morphed into a femmy 1910 Gibson Girl with a frilly parasol. Gone the butch. Gone the butch buddy. Gone the power. Gone the shadow side of mysticism.  


Picture 

Oversize double-breasted men's jacket w/epaulets and shoulder pads and military-style 
armbands on sleeves, with sensible shoes.




And then there was the animation. When Travers signed her agreement, she never dreamed that Disney would be sneaking animation into a film with live actors. Technically, it was not an animated film. He was sticking to the letter of the agreement, but not the spirit. The animated dance sequence took up a remarkable fifteen minutes of screen time. Was he just rubbing it in?   

Not surprisingly Travers raised hell. 

No, Disney did not invite her to the opening. This was a professional insult. Resourceful dyke that she was, she shamed another Disney executive into sending her an invitation. Yes, she wept at the premiere, but they were tears of frustration and disappointment. The animation! At the after-party she confronted Disney. According to Richard Sherman, who co-wrote the music, she declared in a loud voice, “Well. The first thing that has to go is the animation sequence.” Disney looked at her coolly and replied, “Pamela, the ship has sailed.” (She had asked him to call her Mrs. Travers.) 




Picture 
Pink ruffled parasol, see-through sleeves, lace gloves.


Most of the world would now equate Mary Poppins with Julie Andrews’ characterization. Travers' radical revisioning of parenting outside the box of traditional gender roles had been domesticated. And even the Suffragists had been trashed. Mr. Banks was saved. Mrs. Banks was saved. Bert and Mary were saved. And the lesbians were safely back in the closet, banished to a shadow world apart from the nuclear family and disallowed contact with the children.   

I feel for Travers. I feel for her pain in fighting so hard for the real Mary Poppins, but lacking a language and a literature of archetypes to which she could point and say, “No, this is not that! Here is the frame of reference!” But that literature was as censored as her identity. She insisted on being called Mrs. Travers, but there was no husband. There never had been. "Travers" was her father’s first name. How could “Mrs. Travers” possibly, in 1960,  advocate for all of the attributes, affinities, mythological referents that belong to our culture?   




Picture 
PL Travers, Warrior Woman



Short answer: She couldn’t. But she did not pretend to be happy. She did not go gently into the heterotopia of Disneyland. She raised as much hell as she could, but she was outflanked, outmaneuvered, and outnumbered by the strike-breaking, Red-baiting, rabid McCarthy-ite spy who was dictating the so-called family values that would enshrine the patriarch and ensure the compliance of women. 

Italian feminst Carla Lonzi has said,   " Men use myth; women don’t have sufficient personal resources to create it. Women who have tried to do so by themselves have endured such stress that their lives have been shortened by it."   But Travers beat the odds, living to be nearly a hundred. I submit that her fighting spirit, the very spirit so vilified in the movie, had a great deal to do with her longevity. Well-behaved women rarely make centenarians. 

Saving Mr. Banks   is a witch-burning. Make no mistake about that. Give me a film company and I will show you a film about a powerful, visionary, immanently reasonable lesbian fighting off an evil army of propagandists who are hell-bent on breaking the spirit of one of the greatest lesbian archetypes ever set on paper… a liberator of children, a goddess to the natural world, a harbinger of a new order in the wake of the collapse of capitalism. I invite you to imagine and inhabit that scenario, because, sisters, I promise you that it is the real story. 

Categories

Uncategorized

Tags

Black Actresses

Theater

Stereotypes

writing

writing tips

famous authors

writing websites

Pop up gallery

Art Du Nord

visual art

Twin Cities

storefronts

Inspiration

photography

Issey

female

black females

graffiti

money

finances

Mint.com

managing money

language

reference

idioms

Dr. Seuss

quotes that can change your life

Kelly Brazil

found objects

Powerhorn

Minneapolis

MN

home studio

metalwork

Arts on Chicago Project

colors

color palettes

screenwriting

writing exercises

www.screenwritingu.com

design

logo

batman

flowingdata.com

novels

snowflake method

ehow.com

Bb2.0

music

www.onesentence.org

ideas

dance

dementia

Art FYI

Toni Morrison

OpenCulture.com

Sophia Stewart

cautionary tale

script writing

www.thehiphopconsultant.com

Tom Vanderwell

theater

career

education

Tomvanderwell.wordpress.com

artists

teachers

racism

Kodak

Kodak. David Smith

Johannesburg

Guardian.

UK

cards

sarcasm. bitrebels.com

race

art

tcdailyplanet.net

Amina Harper

The Art House

writer

artist

black female

poetry

stumbleupon.com

exercises for poetry

Anne Geddes

black males & doves

inspiration

photo

Teresa Photography

Photos

body image

David Henry Hwang

colorblind casting

Beasts of the Southern Wild

Lucy Alibar

endings

Vulture.com

African American boy

Heidi Grant Halvorson

process

accomplishing goals

successful people

www.inspirebohemia.com

painted rocks

tree trunk played like a record

nature

Jenna Fischer

acting

Juliet Fieldew

www.Dreambreaker.com

creative sites

Justin Pot

How to turn your handwriting into a font

Makeuseof.com

Art: how to

Lemon Anderson

Ted.com

Poetry: Spoken Word

Art: Film & Race

David Sirota

Salon.com

white saviour

oscars 2013

Oscar love a white saviour

KFAI radio

Patricia Nelson

Black composers

classical music

"Classical Mocha"

Call for Submissions

Script writer's contest

Andrea Quijada

Malkia Cyril

Racism

Oscars 2013

"5 Racist Things at the 2013 Oscars"

Hemingway

Urban Dance Camp

Dance!

Les Twins

Music+ Painting

Matteo Negrin

"Lacrime Di Giulietta

" Alice Ninni

Luca Cattaneo

Ka Vang

Hmong writing

MHS Express

Alison Aten

"The Good Hmong Girl Eats Raw Laab"

Paint

Music: Parody

"After Ever After - DISNEY Parody"

Marciano Silva Dos Santos

Aimee Bryant

"Tying the Knot"

Antony Meindl

"How to book the job: fake it 'til you make it"

How to Book the Job: Fake It ‘Til You Make It

How to: Getting the Gig

Missy Whiteman

Lu Lippold

Native film maker

Bill T. Jones/Arnie Zane Dance Company

Dance

Sonya Berlovitz

Costume Designer

Theater: Costume Design

http://www.sonyaberlovitz.com/

Carla Stillwell

plawrighting

black theater

black playwrights

MPAACT

howlround.com

"What Shall We Tell Our Young Playwrights Who Are Black?"

"Masterful music remix of sights and sounds in Kenya"

CBSnews.com

Music: The Remix

Ivo

Milkdreams

Dance: Starting YOung

Henna

Temporary Tattooing

Art: On Skin

"Milkdreams

" Dance: Starting Young

"Self-Publishers: The New Generation of Cool Kids

" Terri Giuliano Long

Writing: Self publishing

Amber Rae

Fast Company

"6 Simple Rituals To Reach Your Potential Every Day"

Art: Paying Attention to Your Spirit

Spirituality

10 Sages With 10 Inspiring Messages

Robyn Robinson

Jewelry

Channeling Your Creativity: Jewelry

www.insightnews.com

Journalist finds another outlet to channel creativity

CHRISTINA GARNER

All Me: The Life and Times of Winfred Rembert

Art: Race

Class

Theater: Acting

john Gielgud

James Grissom

Pablo Picasso

Painting: With Your Hands

Vernon Reid

Gabri Christa Reid

"Savoring the Mellower Music of Home

" John Leland

www.nytimes.com

"‘Voodoo Chile’ Cover on a Gayageum Will Make Your Head Explode"

Music: Mashing of Cultures

Luna Lee

Jimi Hendrix

Julia Halperin

"6 Artists Who Made It Big After Turning 70"

The Artist: The Late Bloomer

Monir Shahroudy Farmanfarmaian

Etel Adnan

Mary Delany

Carmen Herrera

Grandma Moses

Alice Mackler

Deirdre Maloney

Why People Don't Get How Awesome You Are

Self-Improvement

"Mad Girls The story of 20-year-old Sylvia Plath’s “real whirl” in 1953 Manhattan." Cara Parks

Elizabeth Winder

Sylvia Plath

Ed Fuentes

murals

"Photography Turns Street Art and Murals into a Complete Urban Collage"

Rosalind Robertson

depression

Art: Depression

"21 Tips to Keep Your Shit Together When You’re Depressed" www.DIY Couturier.com

Art:The Truth

"Hiring a Musician or Band"

Andrea Kowch

"The Visitors"

Maria Popova

Brain Pickings

"Hello Goodbye Hello

" Craig Brown

Martha Graham

Helen Keller

"Dance Is Like Thought: Helen Keller Visits Martha Graham’s Studio

" Dance

Art: A Witness to Illness

Angelo Merendino

Writing: Straddling a line Between Cultures

www.billmoyers.com

Sherman Alexie

"Living Outside Tribal Lines"

Word Becomes Flesh

Marc Bamuthi Joseph

MAPP International Productions

Intermedia Arts

Theater & Dance: Choreopoem

www.writing.com

Eugene Ionesco

Writing

Edwidge Danticat

Mary Harpin

women writers

"What Everyone Can do to Lift Women Writers: An Interview with Edwidge Danticat"

Writing: Women Writers

Art: Film Resources

PBS.org

Mr. Teachout

"Theater's Expiring Subscription Model"

Art: The Business Side of the Arts

www.online.wsj.com

Rants

Raves and Rethoughts Blog

"All Playwrights Should Self-Produce and Save the American Theatre

" J.C. Lee

Theater:Unique!

Shadow Theater

X-Factor

MNOriginal.org. The Cottmans

Art:Family Affair

Visual Art: Superannuated Surrealist

Oldest living surrealist tells all

Dorothy Tanning

John Glassie

www.salon.com

The Engine of Artistic Innovation. Lojo Smith

Theater: Commentary

Gloria Anzaldua

Women of Color artists

Sculpture

The Colossal

Adam Martinakis

Tamara Natalie Madden

Music: Utterly Fantastic!

Pentatonix

Music: Evolution

Acapella

www.pxofficial.com

How Does Writing Affect Your Brain?

infographic

MICAELA LACY

Trena Bolden-Fields

Acting: Education-- MFA or MA--is it needed to be an actor?

Blogtalkradio

Theater: Workshop (in Minneapolis)-- for parents who want to know the nitty gritty about getting their kids into acting or modeling

Living Against the Grain: Why You Should Stop Apologizing and Embrace Unpopularity

Artists: Being honest with yourself

www.finerminds.com

Erika Napoletano

TED talks

Daisaku Ikeda

Art: Trust who you are

Music: The Brain

Why Music Makes Our Brain Sing

Robert Zatorre

Valorie N. Salimpoor

CYBEL MARTIN

Filming in NYC? AGAIN? How To See It With Fresh Eyes When Working With A Limited Budget

Vigeland Park

Gustav Vigeland

Joss Whedon

Writing: Responsibility

Brian Butler

Artists: Advice

10 Things We Can Learn From Street Artists

Precision Leaf Sculpting

Lorenzo Manuel Durán

Jesse Green

Annie Baker

Playwriting

Ele magazine

Caroline Liem

Acting: Pilot Season

backstage.com

Dallas

Travers

How to Bite Off Only as Much as You Can Chew

ART: Being an Artist

Thandie Newton

Acting: Finding one's self

Julie Miller

Art: Giant Mural

Oscar Oiwa

www.123inspiration.com

Erik Johansson

Art: Inspiration: Manipulation

www123inspiration.com

Art: Produce It Yourself

How to survive being a black actress

Natasha Greeves

Time Bell

When you're ready to hear it!

Cpattonstudio.com

Caymichael Patten

cpattenstudio.com

Zadie Smith

Art: Writing

Dave Lankford

Art: Actors and the Script

50 questions that will free your mind

Art: Pondering

Story About the Story: An Interview with Walter Kirn

J.C. Hallman

www.edisproduction.de

Art: Dance

Art: Artist Life Tips

www.guante.info

Six Things I Wish I Knew When I Was Getting Started as an Artist

Leonardo Da Vinci's wacky piano is heard for the first time

after 500 years

Art: Da VInci and Music

Jewelry made out of disembodied pieces of Barbie dolls

Margaux Lange

AcaBelles

Art: Music--Acapella

Craig Wallace

Why Actors Need to Focus on Talent Before Marketing

Garrett Ayers

Memory Training for Actors: Close To The Tipping Point

Molly Crabapple

Filthy Lucre

10 Tips From Billy Wilder on How to Write a Good Screenplay

Gotham writer's workshop

Mike Springer

Carolyn Gage

Saving Mr. Disney: A Lesbian Perspective

Mary Poppins

P.L. Travers

Joan of Arc

Art: Criminal Artist

Woody Allen

Tanya Steele

'A Dancer Dies Twice': The Unique

Sad Challenge of Retiring From Ballet

MAROOSHA MUZAFFAR

Art: Dance...Retiring from Dance...

Art: Pottery Design

Credit: Krugovorot

Anais Nin

Art:Writing Quote

Art: Music--Fierce Cello Playing

Kim Hines

Amy Rea

Blog Tour

Writing Process

playwrighting process

Art: Mixing Genres

TI

Hugh Jackman

LL Cool J

Tonys

Music Man

Ted Hope

Art: Script Writing & Submission

Ten Things To Do Before You Submit A Script

Alexandria Peary

Yoga for Hands

Art: Inspiration: Being You

Ruth Carter

Costuming

AcademyOriginals.com

Theater: Acting with "disabilities"

Tom Neumeyer

Art: Restoration

5 South Korean Ceramic and Pottery Craftsmen

Art: Master Potters

Chargaux

ART: Violins & Violas--not just for classical music

ART: Forum--the role of art in Society

Disturbing

not pleasing

should be art’s role

Art: Quotes

April Sellers

Ellie Kingsbury

Art: Ellie Kingsbury

Photographer

What's invisible to you?

www.elliekingsbury.com

ART: Creating Dance

Wayne McGregor

ART: Auditions for Actors -- Tips

Self-Taped Auditions

Carey Mulligan

Rebecca Fuller

You Get Better as an Actor Doing Theater

Indiewire

ART: Acting

Visual Art: Journaling

Roz Stendahl

www.rozworks.com

Art: Advice

www.Austinkleon.com/steal

Art: Space

Misty Copeland

Art: Racial Identity

Gustav Gurschner

Art: Art Nouveau

Art: Music and Mechanics

Martin Molin

Hannes Knutsson

Andy Warhol

Art: Truth

Art: Paul Klee

3

900 Pages of Paul Klee’s Personal Notebooks Are Now Online

Presenting His Bauhaus Teachings (1921-1931)

Art:Utilitarian Fantasy

Rebecca O Connell

Rick Kitagawa

Art: Speaking Some Truth Up in Here!

Art: Pace

Art: Painting Portraits

Ryan Hewitt

Portraits

Art: Movement on Paper

Leah Yerpe

charcoal

graphite

drawings

Art: Music Lyrics

The best lyrics

Art: Garden Sculpture

Art: Photography--Surrealism

All Hands and Feet... by Carl G.

Art: Henna (Mehindi) Tattoos

Art: Playwrighting--Process

Playwrights on Process

Art: Tech Theater Folks

JoNel Aleccia

Art: Musical Instruments and Health

"Melody malady: Clarinet player develops 'saxophone lung' from fungus"

Dana Manciagli

"5 tips for making a living (& a life) in the arts

" ART: Making a Living

Art Backup Dancing

Erika Berlin

Mental Floss

Art Brush and Ink

cats

www catzery com

Art Face Detail

Kate Zambrano

Kai Fine Art

Art 10 Emerging Black Female Artists

Shauntay Robinson

Black Art in America

Lavett Ballard

April Bey

Lillian Blades

Bisa Butler

Dana King

Delita Martin

Keris Salmon

Sherry Shine

Beverly Y Smith

Evita Tezeno

Art Using Sunlight in a New Way

60 Second Docs

Sunlight Artist

Mike Papadakis

Kalamarie

ART Podcasts

Top 10 Unapologetically Black Podcasts to Start Listening to Now

Kyle Rich

Facebook